We’ve been talking about this Substitute for Cooking Spray for a couple years now, and finally made a batch live! Whoohoo! Our homemade pan release is easy to make and works like magic!
The trick to a good substitute for cooking spray is adding flour. You know how your grandma used to butter, then flour the insides of the cake pan? There’s a reason she did that!
Homemade nonstick pan release is better than cooking spray because it’s easy to make (you probably have all the ingredients!) and so cheap! It’s great for all cakes and cupcakes, but especially bundt cakes which have so many nooks and crannies!
What can be used instead of nonstick cooking spray?
Our substitute for cooking spray is this magical pan release that is sometimes called goop. It’s a super simple recipe made with vegetable oil, vegetable shortening (like Crisco), and flour.
The most important part of this recipe is the flour, as it’s what helps the baked goods release easily.
How do you grease a pan without cooking spray?
Greasing a pan without cooking spray is easy! Just grab your favorite basting brush (I’m a fan of silicone basting brushes because I feel like they clean easier), dip it in the substitute for cooking spray you just made and paint the surface of your pan.
Make sure to use a nice full coat of pan release, and flip your cake out of the pan while it’s still a little bit warm. I never recommend waiting until a cake is fully cooled, even when using commercial cooking sprays.
Can you use olive oil instead of cooking spray?
I wouldn’t use plain olive oil as a pan release, but you could substitute the vegetable oil for olive oil in this substitute for cooking spray recipe. The caveat will be that olive oil has a stronger flavor than vegetable oil, so if you’re making a delicately flavored dish, you may find that the olive oil changes the flavor slightly.
There are so many variations of olive oil on the market now though that you could likely find a mild olive oil to use if you were so inclined!
Recipes to Make with our Substitute for Cooking Spray
Y’all know I am #NOTABAKER, but that doesn’t mean I don’t love to make a cake. I’m just not making it from scratch. Although, I almost feel like we’re working our way up to it.
Hahahahaha. No, we’re not. Why would we do that when delicious box cake mixes are a thing and it’s so easy to bring them up to the next level with a few tweaks? Check out these amazing desserts that you can make with our easy magic pan release!
- Rainbow Cake – We make this gorgeous rainbow cake in a bundt cake pan and then drizzle super colorful icing all over the top. And don’t forget the sprinkles!
- Orange Cake – Whole oranges, you guys! There are WHOLE oranges in this cake! Is that nuts? What’s nuts is how incredibly delicious it is. Don’t skip the orange juice glaze on top!
- Valentine’s Cake – This pretty pink cake uses conversation hearts to make it alllll about Valentine’s Day – but if you just want a pretty pink cake (who doesn’t love a pink cake?!), then skip the hearts and go all out on the sprinkles!
- Chocolate Overload Cake – Inspired by our trip to Aruba, this chocolate cake not only tastes fantastic, but it brings back so many joyous memories. I hope that when you make it you’ll share it with friends and create wonderful memories too!
- Salted Caramel S’mores Cake – I feel like I just don’t need to say anymore. This cake y’all. This cake.
Tools to make our Substitute for Cooking Spray
- Stick Blender – While you can definitely whisk this together by hand, you’re going to make faster work of it and come out with a smoother result if you use an electric blender. I like an immersion blender like this because it’s no muss, no fuss, and easy to clean up.
- Mason Jars – We store our magic pan release in mason jars in the fridge. I’m a fan of the wide mouth jars so it’s easy to get the brush in and out and make sure you’re getting all the goop.
- Silicone Basting Brush – A silicone basting brush or pastry brush works perfectly to paint the insides of your pan with the non stick cooking release. They also come clean really easily with a little soap and water, and they won’t melt if you use them at high temps, like basting on the grill.
How to Make a Substitute for Cooking Spray
You can also watch us make this Substitute for Cooking Spray on YouTube! Make sure to tune in for all our live cooking shows! Fair warning – we make the baking release while the carrot cake is baking. And it’s not the most graceful episode ever.
Substitute for Cooking Spray
- Vegetable oil
- Vegetable shortening like Crisco
- Combine ingredients in equal parts, then blend until smooth. You could whisk by hand, but I find an electric blender gives a much smoother consistency.
- Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator.
- Brush into your pan with a basting brush, make sure to get in all the crevices and be generous.